EB-1 Extraordinary Ability USCIS Appeal Review – Writer and Filmmaker – MAY192022_03B2203

Date of Decision: MAY 19, 2022
Service Center: Nebraska Service Center
Form Type: Form I-140
Case Type: EB1 Extraordinary Ability

Petitioner Information

Profession: Writer and Filmmaker
Field: Literature and Film
Nationality: Not Specified

Summary of Decision

Initial Decision: Denied
Appeal Outcome: Dismissed

Evidentiary Criteria Analysis

Criteria Met:

Lesser nationally or internationally recognized awards: The Petitioner met this criterion through evidence of awards in the field.
Published material: The Petitioner met this criterion through evidence of published material about his work.

Criteria Not Met:

Participation as a judge: The evidence did not sufficiently demonstrate the Petitioner’s role as a judge of others’ work.
Original contributions: The documentation lacked specific examples of contributions of major significance.
Artistic exhibitions or showcases: The evidence did not confirm that the Petitioner’s work was displayed at recognized artistic exhibitions or showcases.

Key Points from the Decision

Awards and Prizes Won: The Petitioner provided evidence of lesser nationally or internationally recognized awards, which was accepted as fulfilling one criterion.

Published Materials About the Petitioner: Evidence of published materials about the Petitioner’s work was found sufficient to meet this criterion.

Original Contributions of Major Significance: The evidence provided was not sufficient to demonstrate that the Petitioner’s contributions had a major significance in his field. The reference letters lacked specific examples and impact statements necessary to meet this criterion.

Participation as a Judge: The documentation did not provide sufficient details regarding the Petitioner’s activities as a judge, including the specific duties and names of the individuals judged.

Membership in Associations: There was no evidence provided to support this criterion.

Authorship of Scholarly Articles: The documentation did not provide sufficient detail to meet this criterion.

Leading or Critical Role Performed: The evidence was not sufficient to demonstrate a leading or critical role in distinguished organizations.

Artistic Exhibitions or Showcases: The evidence provided did not sufficiently prove that the Petitioner’s work was displayed at artistic exhibitions or showcases.

Evidence of High Salary or Remuneration: There was no evidence provided to support this criterion.

Commercial Successes in the Performing Arts: The evidence was not sufficient to demonstrate commercial success in the performing arts.

Supporting Documentation

  • Letters of Recommendation: Praised the Petitioner’s work but lacked specific examples of significant impact.
  • Film Festival Program: Insufficient to confirm the Petitioner’s participation in artistic showcases.
  • Published Articles: Provided evidence of recognition but did not demonstrate major significance in the field.

Conclusion

Final Determination: The appeal is dismissed.
Reasoning: The Petitioner did not meet at least three of the required evidentiary criteria. The evidence provided lacked specific details and impact statements necessary to demonstrate extraordinary ability.
Next Steps: The Petitioner may seek additional evidence or alternative immigration pathways if applicable.

Download the Full Petition Review Here


Cite as Matter of G-M-, ID# 19646197
Document: MAY192022_03B2203

Izu Okafor
Izu Okafor

Izu Okafor is a filmmaker, project manager, and video editor with a rich background in the film industry. He has refined his craft under the mentorship of industry giants like AMAA VFx Winner Stephen Onaji Onche and AMVCA-winning producer Chris Odeh. Izu is one of 60 participants in the prestigious British Council Film Lab Africa Accelerator Program. His experience spans roles at Sixar Studio, Sozo Films, and Hanuluo Studios, with work on projects like "Wahala" and "Chiugo." He recently produced his debut feature, "Dinobi," which has garnered international festival recognition. Beyond filmmaking, Izu is dedicated to social entrepreneurship and youth empowerment, mentoring future leaders through Uncommon Me International.

Articles: 448

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *