Date of Decision: JAN. 26, 2021
Service Center: Texas Service Center
Form Type: Form I-140
Case Type: EB-1C (Multinational Managers or Executives)
Field of Expertise: Childcare Management
Beneficiary Information
Profession: President of Children’s Daycare Facility
Field: Childcare Management
Nationality: Pakistani
Summary of Decision
Initial Decision: Denied
Appeal Outcome: Denied
Case Overview
The Petitioner, a company operating a children’s daycare facility, sought to employ the Beneficiary as its president in the United States under the EB-1C immigrant classification for multinational executives or managers. The Beneficiary was previously employed in a managerial or executive capacity by a construction company in Pakistan before moving to the U.S. The petition was filed to secure the EB-1C visa, which is reserved for multinational managers or executives who have been employed in such capacities abroad for at least one year in the three years preceding the petition.
Key Issues
The key issues leading to the denial of the petition were centered around whether the Beneficiary had been employed in a managerial or executive capacity abroad. The USCIS found that the evidence provided did not sufficiently demonstrate that the Beneficiary primarily performed managerial or executive duties. Additionally, there were concerns about the lack of specific documentation to support the claims regarding the Beneficiary’s role in managing or directing the operations of the foreign company.
USCIS Findings
The USCIS concluded that the Petitioner failed to establish that the Beneficiary’s previous role abroad met the criteria for a managerial or executive capacity. The decision emphasized the lack of detailed descriptions and supporting evidence for the Beneficiary’s duties, as well as the absence of documentation proving that the Beneficiary supervised professional employees or held significant decision-making authority within the organization.
Supporting Evidence
The Petitioner submitted various documents, including organizational charts and duty descriptions, but these were deemed insufficient by the USCIS. The evidence did not adequately demonstrate that the Beneficiary’s role involved primarily managerial or executive responsibilities, nor did it provide substantial proof of the Beneficiary’s claimed supervisory authority over other employees.
Additional Notes
The USCIS noted that while the Beneficiary held a high-level title, this alone was not enough to meet the requirements for EB-1C classification. The Petitioner’s failure to provide concrete evidence of the Beneficiary’s managerial or executive functions, and the inability to clearly distinguish between qualifying and non-qualifying duties, were critical factors in the denial of the appeal.
Conclusion
Final Determination: The appeal was dismissed due to insufficient evidence that the Beneficiary was employed in a managerial or executive capacity abroad, leading to the denial of the petition.
Download the Full Petition Review Here
